Chimneys, hills and shade: why panel choice matters on a Lancashire roof

Shading costs more output than orientation or panel brand. What shades a Lancashire roof, and the three ways to deal with it.

Shading costs more solar output than orientation, roof pitch and panel brand put together. It is also the thing homeowners think about last, and the thing Lancashire roofs have most of.

Chimney stacks at both ends of a terrace. Valley towns sitting under a hillside that takes the sun away at four in the afternoon. Mature trees in Victorian gardens. Next door's two storey extension. A satellite dish nobody has used since 2014.

None of that stops solar working. But it changes what you should put on the roof, and if the person quoting you has not talked about it, they have not really looked at your house.

This is part of our full guide to solar panels in Lancashire.

Why one shaded panel matters so much

Here is the bit that surprises people. In a basic solar array, panels are wired in a series string, and a series string behaves like a hosepipe. Put a kink anywhere along it and the flow drops everywhere, not just at the kink.

So a chimney shadow falling across the corner of one panel does not cost you one panel's worth of output. Without something in place to handle it, it can drag down every panel wired in with it.

The string effect
One shaded panel, six panels affected.
Basic string wiringshadedAll six pulled down to the weakestWith panel level optimisationshadedOnly the shaded one drops

Modern panels have bypass diodes built in, which split each panel into sections and take some of the sting out of this. It helps. It does not solve it, and it is why the way an array is designed and wired matters as much as what goes on the roof.

Shadows move, and they move a lot

The other thing people miss is that a shadow is not a fixed thing. It travels across the roof through the day, and it changes length dramatically through the year.

In midsummer the sun is high and a chimney casts a short shadow. In December the same chimney casts one several times longer, right across the middle of the day when you are trying to generate. So the tree that clearly does not shade your roof in July may well shade half of it in February.

A chimney shadow through the day
Same roof, same chimney, three times of day.
9am
Shadow west, long
1pm
Short, minimal loss
5pm
Shadow east, long
Illustrative. In winter every one of these shadows is substantially longer.

What shades a Lancashire roof

Chimney stacks. The big one. On a stone terrace you often have two, on the party walls, and they are frequently shared and taller than they look from the pavement.
Hillsides. Rossendale, Pendle, the Calder and Ribble valleys. A hill to your west does not shade your roof directly, but it brings sunset forward by an hour or more and takes the late afternoon generation with it.
Mature trees. Victorian and Edwardian streets have big trees. They also grow, so a roof that is clear today may not be in ten years.
Neighbouring buildings. Two storey extensions, dormer conversions, and on terraces the simple fact that the house next door is the same height as yours and right against it.
Roof clutter. Aerials, satellite dishes, soil vent pipes, flues. Small, easily forgotten, and a thin shadow across a panel is still a shadow.

Three ways to deal with it

1. Design around it

Always the first move and the cheapest. Map where the shadows actually fall through the day and across the seasons, then put panels where they do not go. Sometimes that means fewer panels in a better place, which is very often a better system than more panels in a worse one.

It also means thinking about how the array is wired. Grouping the panels that get shaded together, on their own string, stops them dragging down the ones that do not.

2. Choose panels that cope better

Panel technology has moved on here, and it is the reason we fit Aiko on roofs where shading is a factor.

Conventional panels have metal contact lines running across the front face. Aiko's panels use a back contact design, which puts all the electrical contacts on the rear of the cell instead. According to the manufacturer, that removes the front side shading from those contact lines, delivers module efficiency in the region of 23 to 24 per cent, and provides partial shade optimisation at cell level rather than only at panel level.

In plain terms: more output from the same roof area, which matters on a small terrace plane, and a gentler response when part of a panel goes into shadow.

Being straight about the limits. Better shade tolerance is not immunity. On a genuinely badly shaded roof, a better panel softens the loss but does not remove it, and you will still want optimisation at panel level. Anyone telling you a particular panel makes shading a non issue is overselling it.

3. Add panel level electronics

Optimisers or microinverters give each panel its own control, so a shaded one drops out on its own instead of taking its neighbours with it. That is the second diagram at the top of this page.

They cost more and they add components to the roof, so they are not automatically right. On a clear estate roof they are often unnecessary. On a mid terrace with two stacks and a tree, they usually pay for themselves.

Your roof
What it usually needs
Clear, open, no shading
Good design and a decent panel. Optimisers are usually not worth the money.
Light or occasional shading
Careful string grouping, and a panel with good partial shade behaviour.
Small roof, needs every watt
High efficiency panels. Fewer positions, more output per position.
Genuinely shaded, stacks or trees
Panel level optimisation, plus design and panel choice. All three.

Four questions to ask whoever quotes you

1
Have you done a shading assessment on my roof, or estimated it from an aerial image? Both happen. Only one of them tells you what a chimney does in December.
2
How are the strings grouped? If shaded and unshaded panels are on the same string, ask why.
3
Does the quote include optimisers, and if not, why not? There are good reasons not to fit them. There should just be a reason.
4
What has the shading assumption done to the performance estimate? A figure that ignores shading on a shaded roof is not a figure, it is a guess.

The short answer

Shading is a design problem, not a dealbreaker. We have put good systems on mid terraces with a stack at each end and on houses tucked under a hillside, and they work, because the array was laid out around the shadows rather than in spite of them.

What does not work is pretending the chimney is not there. If a quote arrives with a full roof of panels and no mention of shading, that is worth a question before it is worth a signature.

If you are not sure how much roof you have got to play with in the first place, start with our Lancashire house type guide.

Got a chimney, a tree or a hill in the way?
That is a design question, and we quite enjoy those.
We install solar PV, battery storage and heat pumps on domestic properties across Lancashire and the North West, from Clitheroe. Tell us about your roof and we will tell you honestly what the shading does to it.
Get a free quote01200 411830
Back to News and Insights